I have written Stephen 11 letters over the years. Well, that’s not true. I’ve written something in the area of 40, but I’ve sent 11. And in 9 of those 11 I pitched my idea for his next Great American Musical. Below is my latest.
Dear G-d,
I hope this letter finds you well, and that you are still basking in the glow of your stupendous 80th birthday celebration. As you may have noticed from the ecstatic applause from Orchestra Row G, I thought it was a lovely tribute but stand by my conviction that David H Pierce’s German needs some work. I’d be happy to oblige for your 85th birthday concert. (Or, if you don’t want to wait that long, a private concert in your town-house…? Ha ha! I could bring the deviled eggs! My mother’s recipe, which was really the only good thing to come of that relationship [unless you count the broad shoulders].)
AnysheseriouslyhadbroadershouldersthanJoanCrawford, I’ll cut to the chase, since I know you’re terrifically busy, and that the time spent reading (and answering?) this letter is time away from writing your next masterpiece! (Ideally, one in the “Sweeney” vein. Not that “Road Show” was disappointing!)
As I mentioned in my previous epistolaries, I would like to offer you the unrestricted rights to my life-story - gratis! (As if you need inspiration!) In case you’ve misplaced my previous said correspondence, I’ll just give a quick synopsis here of what I see:
The lights come up on the cramped, dank check-out station of a NY Public Library, where a nattily dressed, balding man on the other side of 60 despondently checks out books to the masses. At 28, his play, (XXXXXXX) had been produced by (XXXXXXX) in an off-Broadway production the Times called “winning” and “insightful,” but then a series of disasters struck – namely, his lover of 18 years getting, fighting, and dying of that fucking disease. You, of course, can balance the maudlin with the funny. And, boy, does it get funny! He spends the next few years grieving, overeating, and getting fired from jobs he didn’t give two shits about, and when he fiiiiiinally felt ready to fall for someone new, he ended up just being a green card angler. Also, he gave me crabs. Uruguayan crabs, which apparently have some special immunity to Permethrin. Way to go, Uruguay. Anyhedeservedtobedeported, save for our hero’s funny, sweet, unemployable younger brother and his girlfriend Patty, who’s only as much of a cliche as the Julianne Moore character was in “A Single Man,” (and yes, I know that Christopher Isherwood penned her first), our balding leading man is alone…except for you. George, spending Sunday in the park, and Giorgio, and Fredrik, and Mme. Armfeldt, and, of course, Phyllis, both young and old. Jesus Christ, Mr. Sondheim; thank you for the Phyllises.
Anylet’stalkaboutcasting… In my last letter, I said John Lithgow could pull it off (if he lays off the Botox), but I now wonder if it might be better to cast a younger actor who might be able to play me in my salad days? Perhaps Cheyenne Jackson? NPH would be excellent, of course – he was so brilliant in Assassins – but he’s busy with his sitcom and his award-show-hosting gigs, and Cheyenne just has so much presence. His thighs alone have more gravitas than the entire cast of “Hair.”
I jest (sort of), but only because my fingers are shaking as I write this. It might appear that my desire to have you score my life is just another example of pathetic New York vanity, but it doesn’t feel like that. It feels like… Like spending all my savings to go to Mexico to try some crazy aloe/cactus/turmeric cure. A crazy, last-ditch effort to salvage something, to make so much nonsense become…sensible.
I’m embarrassing myself. Not as much, perhaps, as when I first saw Terms of Endearment in Union Square Regal and sobbed so hard that I peed myself (true), but close enough.
I look forward to hearing your thoughts. I don’t have a title yet, but you’ve always been brilliant at those, too.
With Utmost Respect and Humility,
XXXXX XXXXXXXXXXX